Save time and money with
Med Tech Market Research


MedTech Business intelligence
supplied through Trade Tracker, Research and Markets and GlobalData

Why Do Drugs Fail?

Publication Date:  September 2008
Publisher: Espicom
Pages: 74
Format: PDF file

Price £995.00
approximately: $1,484 | €1,185

Buy now >>
(managed by Piribo)

Summary

This report analyses recent drug failure events and examines potential areas of remedy for regulators and companies. Greedy companies being economical with the truth? Overzealous regulators pursuing political agendas? Poorly designed or inconclusive clinical trials?

Whatever your view, the failure of a drug late in its development or, worse still, post-launch hurts. It hurts the developer commercially, it hurts the credibility of the regulator, it hurts those patients who are able to benefit from it and it undermines confidence in the industry as a whole.

Statistics may indicate that the rate of drug approval failure hasn't increased, but there has been a succession of failures and withdrawals, some of them very high profile, which have knocked profits, investment and confidence.

What can be learnt from these events and what action can the industry and regulators take to improve their performance in this critical area?

Add to basket >>
(managed by Piribo)

Contents

  • State of the industry and market dynamics
  • State of the industry
    • Figure 1: Pharma industry productivity decline (1995-2007)
    • Table 1: Major drug patent expiries: 2007-2009
  • When do drugs fail?
    • Table 2: Failure rates at each stage of clinical drug development
  • Why do drugs fail?
    • Figure 2: Reasons for attrition
  • Report outline
  • Black box warnings and withdrawals
  • Introduction
    • Table 3: Drugs withdrawn from the market between 1998 and April 2008
    • Figure 3: Rate of safety-based drug withdrawal, 1971-2007
    • Table 4: Examples of black box warnings since 2006
    • Table 5: Drug withdrawals since 2006
  • Case study 1: COX-2 inhibitors (Pain)
  • The facts
    • Table 6: COX-2 inhibitors - Key facts
    • Table 7: Selectivity of the coxibs
  • The fall-out
    • Table 8: Arcoxias FDA review
  • The future
  • Case study 2: Avandia (Diabetes)
  • The facts
    • TTable 9: The glitazones - Key facts
  • The fall-out/li>
  • The future
  • CCase study 3: Lotronex and Zelnorm (Irritable Bowel Syndrome)
  • The facts
    • TTable 10: Lotronex and Zelnorm - Key facts
  • The fall-out
    • Table 11: Post-marketing scenarios for Zelnorm and Lotronex
  • The future
  • Case study 4: Tysabri (Multiple Sclerosis)
  • The facts
    • Table 12: Tysabri - Key facts
  • The fall-out
  • The future
  • Case study 5: Iressa (Cancer)
  • The facts
    • Table 13: EGFR inhibitors - Key facts
  • The fall-out
  • The future
  • Consequences of drug withdrawals and black box warnings since 2004
  • Introduction
    • Figure 4: Key issues arising from drug withdrawals and safety problems since 2004
  • The Food and Drug Administration Amendments Act (FDAAA) of 2007
  • Fast track drug development and accelerated approval in the US and surrogate endpoints
    • Figure 5: Statistics of fast track review (1998 - March 2007)
    • Figure 6: Results of the ENHANCE study with Vytorin (Merck/Schering-Plough)
  • Monitoring the safety of marketed drugs
  • Post-marketing commitments
    • Table 14: REMS negotiated with the FDA since March 2008
  • Changes to direct-to-consumer advertising
  • Differences in regulatory outcome: FDA vs EMEA
    • Table 15: EMEA vs FDA: differences in drug approvals
  • The publics risk perception and communication of safety issues
  • Litigation
  • Conclusions
  • Drug non-app rovals
  • Introduction
    • Table 16: Percentage change in FDA drug decisions: 2006 vs 2007
  • Examples of filing withdrawals, refusals to file and non-approval letters
    • Figure 7: Reasons for filing withdrawals, refusals to file and non-approval letters in US and EU in 2007 and 2008 (to September)
    • Table 17: Non-approval/refusal of marketing applications for new drugs (2007-2008)
    • Figure 8: Critical issues raised by the non-approval of new drugs
  • Credibility of the FDA questioned
  • FDA transparency
  • FDA going against Advisory Committee recommendations
  • Use of surrogate endpoints
  • Requirement for relevant comparative efficacy data
  • Conclusions
  • Late-stage clinical failure and pipeline re-evaluation
  • Introduction
    • Table 18: Phase 3 failure rates in the pharma and biotech industries (2006-2007)
  • Examples of late-stage clinical project terminations
    • Table 19: Examples of late-stage clinical project terminations
  • Case study: Inhaled Insulin
  • The facts
    • Table 20: Inhaled insulin products - Key facts
    • Figure 9: Exuberas product timeline
  • The fall-out
    • Table 21: Reasons for the market failure of Exubera
    • Table 22: Developmental inhaled insulin products
    • Figure 10: Inhaled insulin products from Eli Lilly, MannKind, Novo Nordisk and Pfizer
  • The future
  • Consequences of late-stage failure
    • Figure 11 Critical issues raised for pharma companies by the failure of late-stage development projects
  • Consequences for the therapeutic area
    • Table 23: Final results of the ILLUMINATE trial of torcetrapib
  • Job cuts in big pharma
    • Table 24: Examples of job cuts at big pharma in 2007
  • Consequences for small pharma companies
  • Pipeline re-evaluation
  • Conclusions
  • Discussion
  • Introduction
  • Getting the dose right
  • Pharmacometrics and model-based drug design
    • Figure 12: Points in the drug development timeline that could be influenced by parmacometrics
  • Table of Contents
    • Table 25: Role of pharmacometrics in regulatory review
    • Table 26: Importance of pharmacometric analysis in NDA submissions (2000-2004)
  • Interaction with regulators
    • Figure 13: Opportunities for interaction with the FDA during drug development
  • Real-world clinical trials
  • New technologies and biomarkers
    • Figure 14: Types of biomarker and their uses in drug development and disease management
    • Table 27: Examples of biomarker projects under way as a result of the FDAs Critical Path Initiative
  • Collaboration and open science
  • Progress in translational medicine
    • Figure 15: The learn and confirm model of drug development
  • Development of clinical study expertise
  • Summary
  • Acknowledgement
  • Bibliography & Footnotes
  • Endnotes

Add to basket >>
(managed by Piribo)

To top